Skip to Main Content
Kaylena Marie's Bakery - East Amherst logo topKaylena Marie's Bakery - East Amherst logo scroll
  • Menu
  • Drinks
  • Specials
  • Catering
  • Events
  • Gift Cards
  • Jobs
  • Order
  • Locations

Our Menu

BreakfastLunchCinnamon RollsDessertCakes

Available all day

Breakfast Sandwiches

All breakfast sandwiches are served w/ fresh fruit on the side

Not Your Basic Breakfast Sandwich photo

Not Your Basic Breakfast Sandwich

$8.50
Two eggs scrambled until light and fluffy with melted sharp white cheddar cheese choice of Kaylena’s grilled homemade Italian bread OR homemade soft roll add sliced Smokehouse ham (grilled until slightly crisp) OR grilled sausage patty for $1.50
Focaccia Breakfast Sandwich photo

Focaccia Breakfast Sandwich

$11.85
Sunny side up egg, avocado, sharp cheddar cheese, on Kaylena's homemade roasted tomato focaccia. Add sliced Smokehouse ham (grilled until slightly crisp) OR grilled sausage patty for $1.50
California Breakfast Wrap photo

California Breakfast Wrap

$11.85
Two eggs scrambled until light and fluffy with melted sharp white cheddar cheese avocados seasoned to perfection, cherry tomatoes, baby spinach, wrapped in a soft flour burrito shell add sliced Smokehouse ham (grilled until slightly crisp) OR grilled sausage patty for $1.50
The Sweet and Savory photo

The Sweet and Savory

$15.00
This is HUGE…our signature cinnamon roll is sliced in half and grilled until golden THREE eggs are scrambled until light and fluffy with melted sharp white cheddar cheese topped with grilled sausage AND thinly sliced Smokehouse ham (grilled until slightly crisp), served with maple syrup
Chipotle Power Burrito photo

Chipotle Power Burrito

$14.00
Three egg whites scrambled light and fluffy, topped with white cheddar cheese, grilled ham and sausage, avocado mix, our homemade buffalo hot sauce, wrapped in a soft flour shell burrito

Artisan French Toast

French toast requires 10 minutes on grill

Cinnamon Roll French Toast photo

Cinnamon Roll French Toast

$13.50
Our signature French toast is made with 2 of Kaylena's cinnamon rolls, dusted with powdered sugar, drizzled with glaze served with maple syrup and glaze. Fresh strawberries, blueberries, and blackberries on the side
Cannoli Stuffed French Toast photo

Cannoli Stuffed French Toast

$15.15
One Cinnamon Roll French Toast is topped with Kaylena's Great Great Nana's cannoli filling sprinkled with mini chocolate chips and dusted with powdered sugar, served with fresh strawberries on the side

Bakery Style French Toast

$12.90
Two thick slices of Kaylena's Italian bread grilled to a golden brown and dusted with powdered sugar served with maple syrup and fresh strawberries, blueberries and blackberries on the side

Nutella and Strawberries French Toast

$14.00
Two thick slices of Kaylena's Italian bread grilled to a golden brown and dusted with powdered sugar served with Nutella and a pile of fresh strawberries (whipped cream available upon request)

Yogurt Parfaits / Oats / Toast

Lighter Fare

Mixed Berry Greek Yogurt Parfait photo

Mixed Berry Greek Yogurt Parfait

$8.75
Creamy, smooth vanilla Greek yogurt layered with fresh berries and Kaylena's homemade crunchy granola...served in a large mason jar
Peanut Butter and Banana Yogurt Parfait photo

Peanut Butter and Banana Yogurt Parfait

$9.99
Creamy, smooth vanilla Greek yogurt whipped with peanut butter, layered with sliced bananas and homemade crunchy granola

Steel-Cut Oats

$9.30
A large bowl of warm steel-cut oats mixed with brown sugar topped with Kaylena's homemade crunchy granola and fresh blackberries, blueberries, and strawberries...a wholesome way to start your day!
Avocado Toast photo

Avocado Toast

$12.90
Avocados are seasoned to perfection and drizzled with extra virgin olive oil served on a thick slice of Kaylena's toasted Italian bread and a side of cherry tomatoes...a heart-healthy way to start your day!
Mixed Berry & Mascarpone Toast photo

Mixed Berry & Mascarpone Toast

$11.85
Mascarpone and ricotta cheese are lightly sweetened and topped with fresh blackberries, raspberries, blueberries, and toasted almonds served with a side of Kaylena's homemade granola,...an antioxidant-rich way to start your day!

Peanut Butter & Banana Toast

$13.00
Creamy peanut butter, sliced bananas, and homemade candied walnuts piled on a thick slice of Kaylena's toasted Italian bread served with a side of Kaylena's homemade granola...a protein-packed way to start your day!

Bakery Style Toast

$6.50
Two thick slices of buttered toast made with Kaylena's homemade Italian bread, available with jam or cinnamon sugar, served with fresh fruit

Available all day

Salads & Wraps

All items listed below can be prepared as a salad or wrap (wraps are served with kettle chips)

Autumn Harvest photo

Autumn Harvest

$14.00
Spring mix, cranberries, chopped Granny Smith apples, pecans, shaved asiago, poppyseed dressing (add thick carved turkey or crispy chicken for $2)
Winter Pear and Candied Walnut photo

Winter Pear and Candied Walnut

$14.00
Spring mix, pears, sharp white cheddar cheese, homemade candied walnuts, dried cherries, homemade Dijon vinaigrette (add thick carved turkey or crispy chicken for $2)
Strawberry Spinach photo

Strawberry Spinach

$13.00
Baby spinach, fresh strawberries, toasted sliced almonds, homemade sweet Vidalia onion vinaigrette (contains poppy seeds and sesame seeds) (add thick carved turkey or crispy chicken for $2)
Oriental Chicken photo

Oriental Chicken

$14.00
Spring Mix, shredded carrots, chow mein noodles, toasted sliced almonds, crispy chicken, homemade Oriental vinaigrette

Buffalo Chicken

$15.15
Spring mix, plum tomatoes, shaved asiago cheese, homemade croutons, chicken fingers shaken in medium wing sauce, blue cheese dressing

Sandwiches

All sandwiches are served with kettle chips

Artisan Grilled Cheese

$13.00
Sharp white cheddar and mozzarella cheese grilled on two thick slices of Kaylena's homemade Italian bread until golden brown and the cheese is melted and ooey-gooey delicious

The MacDaddy

$15.00
Our Buffalo Chicken Mac and Cheese is sandwiched between our Artisan Grilled Cheese and grilled to perfection to make the MacDaddy of grilled cheese sandwiches! Available hot, medium, or mild

Classic Turkey

$13.00
Carved turkey, provolone, mixed greens, mayo, served on two thick slices of Kaylena's freshly baked Italian bread
Artisan Turkey photo

Artisan Turkey

$14.00
Thick sliced turkey, melted sharp white cheddar, match-stix Granny Smith apples, mixed greens, honey mustard grilled on Kaylena's homemade Italian bread until golden brown
Grilled Cranberry and Turkey photo

Grilled Cranberry and Turkey

$15.00
Turkey, white cheddar cheese, cranberries, orange zest mayo, and mixed greens, grilled on Kaylena's homemade Italian bread
Grilled Turkey and Avocado photo

Grilled Turkey and Avocado

$15.00
Thick sliced turkey, perfectly seasoned avacado, melted provolone cheese, mixed greens, mayo grilled on Kaylena's homemade Italian bread until golden brown
Grilled Ham and Swiss photo

Grilled Ham and Swiss

$14.00
Thinly sliced grilled Smokehouse ham (grilled until slightly crisp), melted Swiss cheese, sweet and spicy mustard grilled, our special house sauce, on Kaylena's homemade Italian bread until golden brown
Ham and Swiss Sliders photo

Ham and Swiss Sliders

$14.00
Thinly sliced Smokehouse ham, Swiss cheese, sweet and spicy mustard, special house sauce (contains poppy seeds) baked on Two of Kaylena's homemade soft rolls until cheese is melted

Mac and Cheese

Mac and cheese requires 10 minutes in the oven

Three-Cheese Mac and Cheese Skillet photo

Three-Cheese Mac and Cheese Skillet

$14.00
Our housemade cheese and secret seasonings are mixed with noodles until smooth and creamy baked in a cast iron skillet until cheese is bubbling and slightly golden on top
Buffalo Mac and Cheese Skillet photo

Buffalo Mac and Cheese Skillet

$16.25
Blue cheese and mozzarella are added to our three-cheese mac and cheese, then topped with chicken fingers (hot, med, or mild) baked in a cast iron skillet until cheese is bubbling

Due to high demand, we do not accept pre-orders for any cinnamon rolls or specialty rolls. it is first come first serve until we sell out. Thank you for your understanding. We do accept bulk orders of 10 or more for cinnamon rolls

Cinnamon Rolls

Classic cinnamon roll photo

Classic cinnamon roll

$10.00
Our famous, fresh baked, homemade, jumbo cinnamon rolls are our signature item. They are served warm and topped with our homemade vanilla glaze. These are available every day until we sell out

Homemade Pastries & Baked Goods

Dessert

Almond Ring photo

Almond Ring

$6.35/Slice
$45.98/Whole
Our sweet dough is filled with almond filling and brown sugar. Topped with an almond glaze and toasted sliced almonds.
Maple Pecan Twist photo

Maple Pecan Twist

$5.45/Slice
$44.00/Whole
[Seasonal] Rolled with cinnamon filling, pecans, syrup, topped with maple glaze, and pecans.

Cheese Danish

$15.35
[Seasonal] Filled with cheese Danish filling and drizzled with glaze
German Apple Streusel Cake photo

German Apple Streusel Cake

$7.70
4" individual-sized cakes! Apple cinnamon cake topped with glaze and cinnamon crumb topping and drizzled with glaze.
Cannoli photo

Cannoli

$3.96/Large
$38.72/1 Dozen Large
This was originally my Great Great Nana's recipe from Italy. I made my own spin-off of the original recipe. We offer three different toppings. Mini chocolate chips, toasted almonds, and pecans upon request.
Fudge Brownie and Peanut Butter Bars photo

Fudge Brownie and Peanut Butter Bars

$3.50
Fudgy brownies topped with a layer of chocolate ganache. Peanut butter bars are rectangular and filled with a peanut butter filling.
Cheesecake photo

Cheesecake

$4.00/Mini
$7.87/Slice
$59.29/Whole
Our creamy New York Style Cheesecake with a crisp graham cracker crust. Our most popular is the Mini bites with added flavor toppings, prices vary. Toppings include Vanilla bean sour cream, fresh berries, and salted caramel. Other sizes are 4" and Whole cheesecakes.
Fudge Torte photo

Fudge Torte

$4.73/Slice
$33.00/Whole
Decadent chocolate fudge torte covered with chocolate ganache. Traditionally decorated with buttercream around the perimeter. Available with different toppings. Gluten-Free. Fresh Strawberries or Toasted Coconut and Caramel

Pies

$4.84/Slice
Prices vary, and some flavors are seasonal. Fruit pies are made with a tender flaky crust. Key Lime pie has a graham crust, and candy Bar pies have an Oreo crust. Flavors include Dutch Apple with Cinnamon Crumb Topping, Pecan $30.8, Pumpkin, Key Lime, Peanut Butter Pie, and Oreo Pie. 9" available for all pies.

Fresh Baked Cookies

$2.50
Inquire about flavors available when ordering, some are seasonal. 1 dozen or more are open for pre-orders. These cookies have a crisp bottom and chewy center. Chocolate Chip, Peanut Butter, Oatmeal Raisin, M&M, Funfetti, chocolate chip heath, Double chocolate chip, White chocolate cranberry, coconut macaroons, biscotti. We do not accept orders for cutout cookies. We only do Occasion/Seasonal cutouts in our case for purchase, we do not do custom orders.

We Do Not Accept Custom Cake Orders. We Bake Traditional Cakes Decorated With A Universal Design (Rosette Border On The Top Perimeter And A Swirl On The Bottom Border). For Each Size Cake, There Is A Base Price (Prices Vary Based On Flavor). No Refunds On Any Cakes, Unless Returned Within A Day Due To Any Issue, Are Considered Valid For A Refund By The Manager Or Owner. All Cake Orders Require A 2-3 Day Notice. | 6" round cake with filling (serves 6-8) $31.46 | 9" round cake with filling (serves 10-14) $45.98 [standard] | 10" round cake with filling (serves 20-24) $58.08 | 12" round cake with filling (serves 30-35) $62 | Single layer half-sheet cake, no filling (serves 54) $72

Cakes

White Almond

White almond cake with white almond buttercream filling and white almond buttercream frosting. Made with pure sweet almond extract, this cake is elegant and traditional.

Cannoli Cake

This light almond cake is filled with smooth creamy cannoli filling and mini chocolate chips. Frosted with almond buttercream. Three mini cannolis top this cake.
Classic Vanilla photo

Classic Vanilla

Vanilla cake with vanilla buttercream filling and vanilla buttercream frosting. This cake is simple and classic.

Strawberries and Cream

This vanilla bean cake is frosted with strawberries and cream buttercream and piled high with fresh strawberries.

Lemon Zest Raspberry

This fresh lemon zest cake is a bit dense which contrasts nicely with a layer of lemon zest buttercream and crushed fresh raspberries for the filling. It is frosted with lemon zest buttercream and is topped with fresh raspberries.

Triple Chocolate

With two layers of decadent chocolate cake, creamy chocolate buttercream, and chocolate ganache…this cake is pure indulgence.

Black and White

This moist chocolate cake frosted with a vanilla bean buttercream and drizzled with chocolate ganache is a classic.

Oreo

Moist chocolate cake with vanilla bean buttercream, crushed Oreo cookie filling, ganache, and Oreo crumbs on top.

Reese's

Chocolate cake with peanut butter buttercream, Reese's Cup peanut butter filling, chocolate ganache, and Reese's Cups on top.
  • Order
  • Catering
  • Jobs